Best Mascaras For Older Women 2021: Reviews & Buyer’s Guide

This post has affiliate links. At no cost to you, we earn a commision for puchases made through links in this post. Read more

1. L’Oreal Voluminous 2. L’Oreal Voluminous 3. Covergirl Clump Crusher
L'Oreal Paris Voluminous L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Original Covergirl Clump Crusher Mascara

Mascara is a product of make-up that has stood through the tests of time and predates even the Bible! Records from around 4000 BC refer to a substance called kohl that was used to darken the eyebrows, eyes, and eyelashes. It wasn’t until the 19th century that the product we now know as mascara was created by chemist Eugene Rimmel. It doesn’t matter what you’re wearing, where you’re going, how much you spend on it, or how you’re carrying yourself- smudged mascara can ruin your whole look. So what are the best mascaras for older women?

Since the 19th century, cosmetics for beauty have surely seen quite a lot of changes and so has the mascara. Sorting through the thousands of mascaras that have come out since then can be overwhelming, to say the least. This article will be your personal guide to buying the perfect mascara.


What To Look For While Buying Best Mascaras For Older Women

1. Brushes And Wands

When buying mascara to make your look complete, you should look for a brush that fits the shape and size of your eyes. There is a particular science that goes into making a brush. You have to take extra care of everything from its size and shape to the material used for the wand’s bristles that will affect how your eyelashes look.

If you want your eyelashes to have volume without them clumping, it is better to use a mascara wand with long bristles. A wand with shorter bristles will not be able to cover your lashes in one go so you’ll have to apply multiple coats which may end up with you having clumps and–what you may know as–spider leg lashes.

With thick, long lashes, you will require a wand that is made with a cushiony brush material. If you have short, thin lashes, your wand should be made of silicone or rubber material.

The silicone will help more material get transferred to your lashes and not stick to the material. Short and thin lashes won’t be able to push back a cushiony wand like long lashes will so bristles on only one side as a comb would be best suited.

A thick, dense brush will create more voluminous lashes so it is important to consider the shape of your eye and what kind of lashes would suit you better. A wand that is medium-sized, densely packed and has a pointed tip works on all eye shapes and sizes.

2. The Formula Of The Mascara

Along with the wand and brush, take care of the formula of the new mascara! All mascaras use the same basic ingredients–wax, pigments, and film formers. Some brands claim to have innovated their mascara formulations or how they coat or wrap the lashes. The one objective of this list is so that you get clear on which mascara you should buy and I will certainly help you with that.

Asian brands tend to have lighter formulations but they can also make your eyelashes wet and make them stick together and appear thinner. So you might want to steer away from Asian mascara brands.

Since the formulations haven’t changed over the past half-century, you should focus more on the brush than the formulation but still, I will tell you which formula to go for.

You should reach for a water-soluble formula because they are way easier to remove and you won’t have to put your eyes through the torture just to get the mascara off. They are also much better for day-to-day wear. Water-soluble mascaras are much easier to layer, without worrying about flakes or clumps.

You must have seen a lot of advertisements about waterproof mascaras and even though they are made of almost the same ingredients as the water-soluble mascaras, they have a major difference between them. The waterproof quality in them comes from the inclusion of dodecane, which is also used as jet fuel. As a result, these mascaras are also terribly hard to remove.

It may sound novel but this quality of the mascara is really bad for your lashes. You can keep the waterproof mascaras for special occasions as they can be too harsh for daily use and there is no need for your eyes and skin to go through that much trouble.

Instead of buying waterproof mascaras, go for water-resistant ones so that even if you are crying because of a heartbreaking scene in a rom-com, your mascara remains intact. It also comes off way easier than the waterproof mascara.

3. Wear And Tear, Flakes and Clumps

As discussed in the previous factor, quite a lot of brands offer several formulas that make the mascara stay on your eyelashes but it is important to know that if they will come off as easily they get on, without leaving you with eyes like a raccoon or artificially created dark circles.

Another huge annoyance is when you put your mascara on your eyelashes and they make your eyelashes stick to each other or form small gloopy textures in between. It is often experienced by a lot of women that after a long application of the mascara, their eyelashes become stiff, dry and create small flakes. Whatever mascara you’re going to buy, you want to make sure that these things don’t happen with you.

Some mascaras get removed just from one swipe of the makeup remover but some require vaseline or a cream-based formula and excessive rubbing to get them off, especially if you wear contact lenses or have sensitive eyes. I certainly don’t want you to go through the trouble and pain and that is why I’m advising you to check the description of the product before buying it and to read the reviews.

There are also a number of ways that you can smudge your mascara unknowingly: sweat, tears, rubbing your eyes and rain. You need to be extra careful with these kinds of things but if you’re not good with stuff like this and tend to touch your face quite often then I suggest that you should buy a smudge-proof and water-resistant mascara.

If you’ve tried everything from Covergirl to Lancôme, Maybelline to Dior and haven’t found anything worthwhile, this list will certainly help you in your search.

Top 15 Best Mascaras For Older Women 2021

1. L’Oreal Paris Voluminous

L'Oreal Paris Voluminous best mascaras for older womenThis mascara lengthens and volumizes your eyelashes so that you have a full lash fringe that is feathery soft. It is guaranteed to deliver voluptuous volume and intense length without flaking, smudging or clumping. You can use this mascara to get the long, full eyelashes that you wanted.

Available in black and brown as well as washable and waterproof, in packs of one or two, this mascara is quite of its kind. You can complete your eye look with L’Oreal’s collection of smudge-proof eyeliners, define your brows and try your luck with their gorgeous eyeshadow palettes.

The soft wavy bristle brush with over 200 bristles catches every lash and holds the maximum amount of formula for a dramatic volumizing effect. This conditioning lash primer formula, infused with rose oil, helps adhere mascara to lashes for enhanced mascara wear. Made of carnauba wax, water, beeswax and acrylates, this mascara is easily removable with the use of soap and water.


2. L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Original

L’Oreal Paris Voluminous OriginalThis mascara has been uniquely formulated to resist clumping and it builds up and softens the lashes to five times their natural thickness. The Volume Maximising Brush that comes with the mascara thickens lashes smoothly and evenly. This mascara is suitable for sensitive eyes and for those who wear contact lenses.

Another L’Oreal product that can be paired with so many more to get the perfect eye look that you want. The perfect pair with this mascara would be the L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Lash Primer, which is actually available as one of the options while buying this mascara.

The lightweight eyelash primer instantly builds dramatic volume and length on each lash for use under Voluminous mascara so that your lashes can look their best along with you.

For those women who don’t want to hop on the fake lashes bandwagon and want their lashes to look naturally long can opt for this mascara. Reviewers have claimed that the mascara gets gloppy sometimes but it’s nothing that a swipe from a tissue paper can’t solve. A simple facial wipe may not be enough to take this mascara off without you rubbing your eyes vigorously.


3. Covergirl Clump Crusher Mascara

Covergirl Clump Crusher MascaraAvailable in 5 shades, one of them being white, this Covergirl mascara is probably the only mascara you’ll need all your life. This Clump Crusher Mascara gives you 20x more volume without any clumps. This mascara builds your lashes while delivering beautifully separated lashes.

The double-sided brush of the mascara comes in a curved design with straight bristles that fit the curve of the eye, allowing root-to-tip volume. One of the shades that this mascara offers, black shade is ideal for any skin tone, eye color, or age. The brush with lash-loading and clump-combing zones ensures root-to-tip volume and even mascara distribution​.

This is a 100% vegan mascara and contains no phthalates, mineral oil, formaldehyde, talc, parabens, or sulfates​. Pro-tip: Apply Covergirl Lash Blast Amplify Eyelash Primer first for an even bigger lash boost.

When both are applied together, you will get double the amount of compliments and water-resistance. Not only does the primer help you keep your look for way longer, but it also helps keep the mascara from getting drying and becoming stiff and dry.

For those who don’t wear makeup regularly and have naturally short eyelashes, this mascara is the perfect one for you. It allows you to have a neutral look and at the same time, makes your eyes pop.


4. Natural 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara

Natural 4D Silk Fiber Lash MascaraThis deeply pigmented mascara instantly creates beautifully dramatic and bold lashes with just a single application that brings out the beauty of your eyes and compliments your whole look. This waterproof and long-lasting Mascara formula ensures that your eyelashes stay gorgeously long, thick and voluminous all day through rain, sweat, and tears.

The smooth and creamy mascara sweeps across all lashes without clumping, flaking, or drying out, creating attractive and flawless eyelashes with just one single application. And this mascara is extremely easy to remove! You just have to use your makeup remover and viola! You’re done!

This hypoallergenic 4D silk fiber lash mascara contains gentle ingredients that are safe and friendly for contact lens wearers and those with sensitive eyes. Most of the customers who’ve bought mascaras all their life and then landed on this product have exclaimed that it is the best mascara that they’ve used.

One of the reviewers said that once she had put on the mascara for 11 hours and experienced no clumps. She also said that it felt like it had lifted or curled her eyelashes. Other consumers also claimed that this mascara made their eyes pop and make their face look fresher but still maintained a neutral look. It is super easy to apply and just as easy to remove.


5. Maybelline Full ‘N Soft Washable Mascara

Maybelline Full 'N Soft Washable MascaraAvailable in two colors, this mascara has an advanced thickening formula that nourishes with Vitamin E to create softer & fuller looking lashes. It removes easily to help prevent lash loss. The ingredients that it is made out of makes it safer for those who use contact lenses towear.

Maybelline is the one brand that is as wholesome as any other with a wide range of products. Whatever your signature eye look, natural or dramatic, Maybelline’s highly pigmented eyeshadows, iconic mascaras, and liquid eyeliners will help you complete your look.

Rather than buying painful to remove waterproof mascaras, you can buy this water-resistant mascara and notice, as many of the people who’ve bought this mascara have, that it lasts longer.

This mascara is very versatile and can style you up for a day in the office to a night out later with your friends. Some of the people who’ve bought this mascara have gone swimming with it and it has STAYED ON. The swimming didn’t clump the lashes either.


6. 400X Pure Silk Fiber Lash Mascara

400X Pure Silk Fiber Lash MascaraThis mascara lengthens and volumizes short, sparse and thin lashes. You can actually achieve the look you want without using expensive and heavy false lashes. This Mia Adora 3D Fiber Lash Mascara will build your natural lashes up to 300%.

I know what you must be thinking: This is too good to be true. I will tell you about the secret ingredient that makes this mascara special: natural, green tea micro fibers that work like tiny extensions to boost length and volume. When these extensions are applied to wet mascara, it volumizes and intensifies your natural lashes.

Paraben and SLS free, Mia Adora Beauty’s products are completely natural and they operate in consideration with American standards. They function animal and human cruelty-free and are the friendliest customer service on the planet.

Unlike most eyelash products, this mascara’s non-toxic clump-free formula will condition your lashes instead of damaging them! By following the detailed instructions that the company provides, you can have the longer, thicker lashes you’ve always wanted in a simple 3 step application.

As you age, eyelashes become more short, thin and fragile. This is why the company has a diverse range of repeat customers; with customers as young as teenagers and many mature women in their 40’s, 50’s and 60’s.


7. Bestidy 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara

Bestidy 4D Silk Fiber Lash MascaraAvailable in the body of a shiny pink, this mascara provides your lashes with instant volume and length so that you can effortlessly achieve your desired look. This waterproof and long-lasting Mascara formula ensures that your eyelashes stay generously long, thick and voluminous all day through rain, sweat, and tears.

This mascara’s advanced thickening formula creates softer and fuller-looking lashes. Your eyes will be protected by the natural and non-toxic formula. Even those who have sensitive eyes and those who wear contact lenses.

Your morning routine will be a breeze if you get this mascara. It is good for parties and special occasions as well. The small bottle that the mascara comes in makes it very portable so that you can carry it in your purse and then touch-up on your eyelashes whenever you want; not that you’d need to.

The mascara wand comes with a grip so that you can hold and apply it properly. Those who bought and reviewed the product said that they found no clumps when they applied the mascara and even when one of the reviewers was cutting onions and tearing up, the mascara remained intact.


8. Maybelline Volum’ Express Colossal

Maybelline Volum' Express ColossalThis mascara will provide your lashes with root-to-tip volume in power colors for bold lash impact! The formula infused with collagen delivers in one coat nine times the volume and no clumps. A new edition of the mascara is also available in a pack of two if you’re planning to take a long trip and the itinerary you’ve planned gives you o time for shopping.

The Big Shot brush of the mascara features wavy, unique bristles that cradle lashes while the collagen formula delivers dramatic volume. The mascara has been tested by ophthalmologists and is suitable for those who wear contact lenses.

You can find your perfect lash look with this mascara. If you crave longer lashes or thicker lashes, you can get any look you want with the line of mascaras that Maybelline has to offer. The products that Maybelline offers gives you an immense amount of possibilities that will transform your look in the blink of an eye.


9. Simply Naked Beauty Lash Science 3D

Simply Naked Beauty Lash Science 3DWith this smudge-proof and waterproof lash mascara, you can get up 300X lash volume in under 5 minutes. It is guaranteed that the Lash Science 3D fiber mascara with 100% USDA certified castor oil will give you the most volume and length outside of extensions.

You don’t have to worry about your lashes once you’ve applied this mascara. It will last all day no matter what you’re doing while providing the biggest ever lash volume and length. The package of Lash Science Gold includes 3 tubes, the company’s standard Lash Science Gel & Fiber and an advanced nourishing mascara that aids lash growth.

The gold mascara is very good, and it comes with an hourglass-shaped brush and has a good consistency. The only issue that people might run into is when the gel gets onto your lid or another surface.

You can use a makeup remover pen to take it off, as just a Q-tip doesn’t really get it off–it is pretty permanent. However, at night, your makeup remover can take it all off easily after the shower without a mess. Your eyes won’t get puffy or red at night from irritation from using this product.


10. Clinique High Impact Curling Mascara

Clinique High Impact Curling MascaraThis is the one mascara I have been very excited to introduce to you. This is the mascara that makes the top of the list of the best mascara for women over 50. You can say goodbye to dark circles while using this mascara. Compared to other mascara brands, this mascara comes through with all promises and lands on all your expectations.

All it takes is warm water to remove this mascara. In fact, if you wet your face in the shower, you can gently pull the mascara off as though it were little mascara tubes on your lashes. You won’t even need to apply the makeup remover–that might get in your eye–to remove the mascara.

One of the people who bought the product has reported that you just need to pay it a little bit of attention while you’re actually applying it on your lashes.

Once a single coat is applied, you need to continue to coat and separate the lashes from each other. It makes a big difference in how it looks if you get as close as possible to the base of the lashes. The biggest advantage of this mascara is that it doesn’t require a second coat.


11. Mary Kay Lash Intensity Mascara

Mary Kay Lash Intensity MascaraIf there’s any mascara that checks all the boxes that you have in your personal list while looking for mascara, this is the one you’ve been looking for. It is easy to apply, just as easy to remove, it doesn’t smudge, and has lash lengthening and thickening properties.

As we get older, our lashes and brows begin to thin and their regrowth is quite slow. If you aren’t careful, while using an eyelash curler, you might even pull out or break a few eyelashes. You have to be very gentle while doing anything with your eyes and avoid rubbing them as much as possible.

A good mascara can not only help you keep the appearance of long, lush eyelashes and with Mary Kay Lash Intensity Mascara, you can sure believe that they will go a long way to help you achieve that. The mascara is a rich, beautiful and deep black and is quite alluring to look at.

The brush that comes along is probably one of the reasons that this mascara is so popular. It is designed to give multi-directional coverage and if my analysis of customer reviews is accurate, it does quite that. It covers smoothly and quickly in just one coat and remains on your eyelashes the whole day. It only comes off with soap and water or a non-oily makeup remover.


12. Lancome Monsieur Big Volume Mascara

Lancome Monsieur Big Volume MascaraThis mascara is certainly one of those that needs to be on your go-to list. Lancome has certainly outdone itself with this mascara which has most of the attributes that the other mascaras also have, including the non-smudge feature which makes it the top choice for a lot of women.

The brush of the mascara is one of the reasons many of the reviewers have a lot of positive feedback to give about the mascara. It distributes just the right amount of mascara to the eyelashes on the first application which is essential if you have thinning eyelashes.

This rich and dark mascara allows you to work on your eyelashes so that you can have the effect or volume you wanted and it doesn’t dry out too quick either. What else could you possibly want?

One of the reviewers has said that if you apply it directly from the base of the lashes up, it gives the effect of having an eyeliner without going through the trouble of actually applying it. The product claims to be smudge-proof but after reading some reviews, I can easily conclude that after going under water, it has turned to be pretty average in the area.


13. Neutrogena Healthy Lengthening Mascara

Neutrogena Healthy Lengthening MascaraThis mascara with its unique lash lengthening formula is one of the most desired after products on Amazon. Consisting of Vitamin E and olive oil for deep nourishment, the Neutrogena Healthy Lengthening Mascara keeps the promises its name suggests. It helps lengthen and strengthen the lashes from the root to the tip.

The gentle bristle brush combs through each and every lash, applying the antioxidant ich color to instantly intensify the look of the lashes. You will find no clumps, flaking or smudges when you apply this mascara. It’s ophthalmologist-tested so it’s great for those with sensitive eyes and the people who wear contact lenses.

This mascara is exclusively good for those who have sensitive skin and/or eyes and as far as the reviews have told me, it stands up to the promise. People who had been looking for a mascara everywhere which wouldn’t irritate their skin or eyes have landed upon this mascara and ever since then, they have not switched over to any other.


14. Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara

Honest Beauty Extreme Length MascaraThis two-in-one primer and mascara works together for lush length, volume and definition of your lashes. The primer coats your lashes to create an even base so that the color of the mascara gets intensified which makes your eyes appear like the star of the show.

The rich mascara applies smoothly and uniformly for dramatic length and sky-high lift. This 2-in-1 dual-ended primer and mascara, which has been tested by ophthalmologists and dermatologists, is cruelty-free and perfect for sensitive eyes because it doesn’t contain any parabens, paraffins, mineral oil, silicone or synthetic fragrances.

The specially molded bristles pick up every single eyelash for expert definition. For the women who have extremely short eyelashes and it is quite difficult for them to find mascaras that actually make their eyelashes look lush, then this is the mascara for them.

This mascara is waterproof, so much so that one reviewer who has oily skin didn’t have any smudging. She, although comes clean with the fact that the mascara is not cry proof. Super easy to remove, it doesn’t tear out any eyelashes and is perfect for those who have sensitive skin.


15. Maybelline Lash Discovery

Maybelline Lash DiscoveryThis exclusive lash-catching mini-brush allows you to get hard-to-reach lashes – from corner to corner and root to tip and the bottom. This mascara lengthens and defines lashes like no other and delivers without any clumps or globs. While your lashes aren’t going to appear super dramatic, you will get just enough curl to draw attention to your eyes.

It is safe for those who wear contact lenses and are hypoallergenic. It is easily removed with the use of water and is available in waterproof formula. It has a very natural effect on your eyes and is recommended by a lot of makeup artists.

Considering Maybelline is quite cheap, you can both the regular and the waterproof version and use the former one for your top lashes and the latter for your bottom ones so that you can avoid raccoon lashes.

st[p]cjdw1p21700lfhnyerphrl8bk[i]oWLuOE&tag=seniorjoy-20&th=1″ style=”flat” background=”#ffcc00 ” size=”10″ radius=”0″]CHECK THE CHEAPEST PRICE ON AMAZON!

FAQs on Mascaras For Older Women

1. How Hard Is It To Remove Waterproof Mascaras?

While the waterproof mascara provides you with quite a few advantages like being safe from any kind of liquid and avoiding raccoon eyes, it is quite a pain to remove.

Some customers that have bought waterproof mascaras have had to use vaseline or other cream-based products to remove the mascara which can mistakenly get into your eye and cause damage. You can also use moisturizing soaps to soften the waterproof mascara and then remove it with water.

2. Will The Water-resistant Mascaras Be Able To Survive Humid Weather?

It is highly improbable that water-resistant mascaras will not be able to survive humid temperatures. If you don’t apply more than two coats of mascara on your lower lash, you will not suffer with a case of raccoon eyes either.

3. What Type Of Mascara Comes Off Easily At The End Of The Day?

A washable or water-soluble formula of a mascara is much easier to take off than a waterproof or water-resistant mascara.

4. Can Dried-up Mascara Be Reused?

No, and you shouldn’t add any form of liquid to said dried-up mascara to make it “reusable”. Adding water to the formula may introduce bacteria and will dilute the preservative that is intended to protect against microbial growth.

We hope this article helped you narrow down to a select few mascaras that you’d like to try out. Happy shopping!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *