Best Eyeliners For Older Women 2021: Reviews & Buyer’s Guide

This post has affiliate links. At no cost to you, we earn a commision for puchases made through links in this post. Read more

1. Stila Stay All Day 2. Covergirl LashBlast 3. Rimmel Exaggerate
Stila Stay All Day Best Eyeliner For Older Women Covergirl LashBlast Volume Mascara Rimmel Exaggerate Eye Definer Pencil Eyeliner

The older you get, the harder it gets to find an eyeliner that not only suits you but also your skin, causing no damage when applied. As you age, the skin around your eyes starts thinning.

Stabbing it roughly with eyeliners will only cause more wrinkles and fine lines to spread. If the one you have currently is constantly tugging the area around your eyes, the problem will only escalate.

If we consider how we also need eyeliners to be smudge-free, non-runny and the kind that won’t irritate your eyes, finding the best eyeliners for senior women who are around or over 50 seems impossible.


Fortunately, they do exist- even if it may not be easy to find them.

In fact, not only are there eyeliners specifically for older women, but they are also made with the intent to make your eyes look relaxed and glamorous. As such, we’ve selected top beauty products comprising of 10 best eyeliner for older women that will showcase your eyes without ruining your skin.

Why You Should Change Your Eyeliner When You’re Older?

The skin around your eyes is delicate even when you are young. As you get older, the skin only gets thinner and more susceptible to damage. Any kind of friction, such as deliberately rubbing your eyes, can be bad for it. Even something as simple as pulling the skin around your eyes when you are trying to apply your eyeliner can result in pronounced wrinkles.

This means it’s necessary that when you choose a product, you settle for the ones where the application is smooth so the skin around your eyes is not tugged at.

For those who have sensitive skin or use contacts daily, it’s also better to choose eyeliners where the use of chemicals is low and the formula actually has some nourishing qualities so that the eyes don’t get dry or irritated.

If you have oily lids, you might feel more at ease with powder and pencil ones over liquid and gels. For women who have dry skin, on the other hand, products that provide an extra bit of hydration, such as the ones that contain aloe, are more suitable.

Types Of Eyeliner

Before you can take a look at eyeliners that will fit your current skin condition, let’s first understand the type of eyeliner you should be looking for. In case you aren’t aware, eyeliners don’t come in only one size that will fit all eyes. The advantage of eyeliners also differs from one another.

There are women who would rather go for a liquid or gel eyeliner which is the right choice when you plan it to give sharp wings to your eyes.

While others might lean more towards powdered or crayon ones that allow one to give a more smoky look to one’s eyes. Pencil eyeliners have the advantage of fitting both these criteria, but they also add a dash of extra, pop up color to your eyes. Let’s take a look at some of the different types.

1. Gel Eyeliner

As the name suggests, these eyeliners have a more gel-like finish. They are good whether you want to opt for thin or thick lines. It is, however, slightly harder to control, especially if you aren’t that good with makeup. However, this type of eyeliner also has a longer staying power and the pigment is darker and bolder.

2. Crayon Eyeliner

The crayon eyeliners lie somewhere between a gel and pencil. The consistency is creamier with this one and it doesn’t cause your skin to dry easily. If your eyelids are usually dry, these ones would be more suitable for you. The application is also smoother so you don’t have to apply pressure which would further hurt your eyes.

3. Liquid Eyeliner

Yes, it has a more liquid feel to it. The application is startingly smooth and you can wield the best control over this kind of eyeliners. It’s also smudge-proof so you don’t have to worry about it making a mess around your eyes throughout the day. These kinds of eyeliners are perfect for days when you have to be out for a long period of time. In fact, you can never really go wrong with liquid eyeliner.

4. Pencil Eyeliner

If you want to have precise control over your eyeliner, the pencil one is your friend. While it’s true that a lot of pencil eyeliner is responsible for dragging and tugging your skin, especially the older ones, the newer innovations have become much smoother.

5. Powder Eyeliner

Powder eyeliners are also called shadow eyeliners. You can try and create straight lines with this one but it can be hard to accomplish for novices. Instead, these have the advantage of giving your eyes a carefully planned smudge appearance.

6. Felt-Tip Eyeliner

These are also called pen eyeliners. This is like a mixture of liquid and pencil eyeliner. It allows you quite the control and has high pigment. They are also on the long lasting side. As such, they are ideal for when you simply want to touch up your appearance.

Now that we understand why it’s important to choose a particular kind of eyeliner for older women and the types that are available, let’s take a look at the 10 best eyeliners for older women.

Top 10 Best Eyeliners For Older Women 2021

1. Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

Stila Stay All Day Best Eyeliner For Older WomenFrom Stila, this liquid eye liner comes with both micro tip and marker tip. It’s also available in ranges of color starting from a dark and intense black to Alloy, Dark brown, Indigo, Midnight and white- depending entirely on your preference. If you are the type that loves experimenting with your looks, you will certainly prefer Indigo, Alloy or White.

The marker tip is made in such a way that regardless of whether you are a pro or novice when it comes to eyeliner application, you would be able to give yourself the precise and perfect look you are aiming for. You can also experiment as much as you want with this one. You can go for a really thin, sharp line look to something more dramatic, thick and eye-catching.

The company also recommends that you shake the eyeliner a few times before you apply it. This way the liquid would be more spread out inside the pen. When you are aiming for a dramatic effect, sweep the pen along your lashes. When the aim is a thin look, use the tip of the pen to do it.


2. Covergirl LashBlast Volume Mascara

Covergirl LashBlast Volume MascaraFrom Covergirl, we get mascara and eyeliner in one smooth package. While our personal favorite is the Black Onyx from the company which gives a really dark look, you can also go for Blue Cobalt, Bold Cobalt, Charcoal, Espresso, Grey Khaki, Midnight Blue or White Out. Of course, if you fall in love with the company’s eyeliner style, you could simply buy all of them and have fun arranging your look for every day of the week.

The Pointy eyeliner is a long-lasting one. It’s waterproof and you don’t have to worry about damaging your skin if you use this one a little too often. It’s also something you can wash off quite easily with the right wiper. The company takes great care in making its product bright but natural looking.

The best thing about this eyeliner is how versatile it is. There’s a smudger tip on the opposite side which you can use to blend the eyeliner you have applied, allowing your eyes to get a more smoky glow. You also don’t have to sharpen the tip. It self sharpens according to your needs.

Cruelty Free International also gives the company Leaping Bunny Certificate for all its products. This means you don’t have to worry about contributing to animal cruelty while using this one. We’re quite confident about calling it one of the best eyeliners for older women.


3. Rimmel Exaggerate Eye Definer Pencil Eyeliner

Rimmel Exaggerate Eye Definer Pencil EyelinerOne of Rimmel’s best products, this pencil eyeliner is a high impact one. The Rimmel product also has a smudger and sharpener built-in, saving you quite the hassle of buying other makeup products to go with it as well as making it easier for you to apply makeup without hunting for all your makeup items.

It has high pigmentation and the shades go from metallic to creamy matte. It’s easy to control and you can aim for precise strokes. It also blends well with the eyelids giving you a natural but strong look. Made with a color intense formula, the eyeliner is also waterproof. It’s overall staying power is quite good as well, amounting to 10 hours a day.

Rimmel’s entire makeup line is aimed at an edgier audience. Just because you are older doesn’t mean you can’t give yourself a dark, intense attitude and Rimmel does it effectively with this eyeliner. You will also be quite amazed at how relatively inexpensive it is compared to a lot of pencil eyeliners in the market.

While the shades are mostly black, the company also has some blue and brown to throw in the mix.


4. L’Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Pencil Eyeliner

L'Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Pencil EyelinerWhen it comes to beauty products, L’Oreal Paris will always have a bit of an advantage. They didn’t disappoint when it came to their eyeliner either. This mechanical pencil comes with a sharpener built-in and offers a smudge-free application.

It’s a creamy eye pencil with a rich texture that ensures the eyeliner glides over your eyelids stays on for at least 16 hours. The color won’t fade no matter how much you have used this one.

The eyeliner is quite versatile in terms of applicability, as you can opt for a really bold, smudges look with the smudger or go for a more classic, regular eyeliner application. Not needing another sharpener for the eyeliner certainly makes it easy to categorize this one as one of the best eyeliners for older women.

The shades for this one range from black, black-brown and regular brown to Navy, Slate, White and Carbon Black. The pigment is quite intense here, which is what makes it easy to define your eyes the way you want them to. The versatility also ensures that you can dress up for any occasion with this eyeliner.


5. Physicians Formula Lash Boosting Eyeliner

Physicians Formula Lash Boosting EyelinerIf you can get an eyeliner and eyelash booster serum in one single pen then why wouldn’t you? Physicians Formula is certainly willing to provide us with an eyeliner that has the ability to do both. For the eyeliner, it has the precision and definition we are looking for when doing our makeup and comes with high pigmentation to make sure it’s eye-catching.

Then, we have the eyelash booster serum which provides both nourishment and conditions your eyelashes. If there was any chance of the eyeliner causing any kind of damage to the area around your eyes, the serum ensures that it won’t ever happen.

If you want, you can use the serum without using the eyeliner or you could combine it with the eyeliner to complete your under-eye makeup. The lash boosting formula in it precisely targets the base where your lashes are at, so this way, the treatment is quite deep.

Physician Formula also takes great care to make their product is hypoallergenic. The products are quite safe for those who have sensitive skin and eyes. You won’t feel the familiar prickling of tears while applying the eyeliner with this one. The company also steers clears from any harsh product that is usually used for personal care items.


6. Docolor Pen Liquid Eyeliner

Docolor Pen Liquid EyelinerFor one, liquid eyeliner is a long-lasting one. The product will last on your eyes for at least 24 hours, so you are bound to look good and ready for the better part of the day. The flow of this one is something a lot of other companies would envy. It’s perfectly smooth that you shouldn’t have any problem aiming for the winged lines or for the cat-eye look.

It’s a liquid felt tip eyeliner so it makes for quite the precise application. Women who have particularly sensitive skin or wear contact regularly would enjoy this one over anything else. The pigmentation is high so the colors are defined when you apply it.

It’s also resistant to water and has smudge-proof properties. This is one of the best eyeliners for older women, for this reason, especially the ones who have to be out for work all day.

You can be also assured that there aren’t any chemicals used in the formula that could trigger your allergies. You can opt for both natural and dramatic tone with this one.


7. Covergirl Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil

Covergirl Perfect Blend Eyeliner PencilThis pencil eyeliner is particularly good for women who prefer blending their eye makeup for a powerful appearance.

It glides so smoothly over your eyelids and skin that you never have to worry about it contributing to your wrinkles in any way. You can draw precise lines so you get the defined look or you can use the blender tip of the eyeliner so your makeup is smudged softly.

Covergirl also promises long-lasting effect on all its products. It’s helpful that the company aims to please older women and wants to make sure you never age in appearance if their products have anything to say.

The makeup quality is almost at a professional level, ensuring you have a radiant and natural beauty visible with the eyeliner and all its other products.

The one we like a lot from the company has a shade called 110 Black Brown and the size count is 2 for this one. It’s also on the inexpensive side of things so you don’t feel guilty about spending a whole lot on your makeup.


8. Maybelline Eyestudio Master Precise

Maybelline Eyestudio Master PreciseHow could we talk about eyeliners and never mention one from Maybelline? The company will always find its way into the list for best eyeliners for older women or in any makeup category really.

The lines you draw are sharp and precise with this product. The color is intense and you can be assured it won’t smudge and ruin your look throughout the 12 hours lasting period.

The rich, colorful shades also allow you to have many choices with your look. You can go for the usual dramatic effect with the black pen or let the green and blue eyeliner show your playful side even at an older age. Or you could go for the more natural and soft look with the brown color. As the eyeliner is waterproof, you will certainly need a makeup remover to wipe it off.

As the tip is quite sharp, the company also feels the need to give out a warning that you shouldn’t use this product if you are in a moving vehicle.


9. L’Oreal Pro-Last Pencil Eyeliner

L'Oreal Pro-Last Pencil EyelinerGliding it along your eyes is so easy when you are using a L’Oreal Paris product. Longer than most eyeliner products in the market, this smudge-free and water-resistant product actually lasts for 24 hours. The easy tip allows you to opt for a natural, everyday makeup look or go for the bolder and everyone’s favorite cat-eye combination.

The colors are quite intense and have such a creamy texture to it that you feel at ease after you have applied the product. The shades available are Brown, Aubergine, Bronze, Burgundy, Ivy and so much more. The product is also available in size count of both 1 and 2.

The company is quite strict about not applying the product when you are inside a moving vehicle. You should also refrain from applying the cosmetic if you have scratches or cuts around your eyes.


10. Hairgenics Pronexa Lavish Liner

Hairgenics Pronexa Lavish LinerThe company is quite proud of this invention of theirs and seeing as this has made it into the list of best eyeliner for older women, it’s easy to see they have every reason to be.

The eyeliner pen comes to you with a formula that involves serum and castor oil mixed in so that it could boost the growth of your eyelashes. The tip is so smooth that whether you aim for a cat-eye or controlled tight lining, you would be able to glide it over easily.

The intuitive pen makes sure you don’t end up using more liner than necessarily with how precise the brush is. It’s made with the smudge-proof and water-resistant formula and so, it stays with you throughout the day. In fact, unless you remove it with makeup remover or soap, it won’t leave your eyelashes.

The castor and serum formula work together to ensure that your eyelashes become thicker and even longer. According to the company, you can see the result in just about 60 days of using it.


Best Eyeliners For Older Women – Final Thoughts

Having gone over the 10 best eyeliners for older women, we can establish confidently that they are all different from each other and what you should buy depends on a variety of factors, including your skin type.

Regardless, we are certain that you will be able to find at least one eyeliner from this list that would suit what you are aiming for and would be comfortable for your eyes!

Don’t take too long to decide though!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *